Partilinjen
DecidedDecided 13 June 2024

Granskning av rotavdragets kostnader och effekter

Official title: Riksrevisionens rapport Svart på vitt – rotavdragets kostnader och effekter

Riksdagen har behandlat Riksrevisionens granskning av rotavdraget och regeringens svar på rapporten. Riksdagen beslutade att lägga regeringens skrivelse till handlingarna och därmed avsluta ärendet.

In brief

What the Riksdag decided

Beslutet innebär att riksdagen avslutar ärendet utan att kräva några ändringar i rotavdraget. Riksrevisionen konstaterade i sin rapport att rotavdraget minskar svartarbete men ger mycket liten effekt på arbetsutbudet och inte motiverar statens kostnader. Regeringen delar inte fullt ut den bilden utan anser att samhällsvinsten av minskat svartarbete underskattats och planerar inga ändringar utifrån rapporten.

What was contested

S röstade nej till utskottets förslag och V avstod, båda med egna motivreservationer. Partierna kritiserade regeringen för att inte följa Riksrevisionens rekommendation om att sänka taket för rotavdraget och menade att regeringens politik främst gynnar höginkomsttagare.

This summary was written with the help of AI from the committee report and the votes. It is not an official text – always read the Riksdag's own description. The English text is a machine translation of the Swedish summary.

The vote

13 June 2024

1. Riksrevisionens rapport Svart på vitt - rotavdragets kostnader och effekter (reasoning)

Riksdagen lägger skrivelse 2023/24:125 till handlingarna.

180
Yes
93
No

19 abstained · 57 absent

The committee's reasoning prevailed · MP and C voted with the Tidö parties

THE SPEAKERDEPUTY SPEAKERSCABINET BENCHKenneth G Forslund (S) – No · seat 1Julia Kronlid (SD) – Yes · seat 2Kerstin Lundgren (C) – Yes · seat 3Anders Ygeman (S) – No · seat 4Margareta Cederfelt (M) – Yes · seat 5Karin Enström (M) – Yes · seat 6Mikael Damberg (S) – No · seat 7Johanna Hornberger (M) – Yes · seat 8Fredrik Olovsson (S) – No · seat 9Helena Bouveng (M) – Yes · seat 10Hanna Westerén (S) – No · seat 11Jesper Skalberg Karlsson (M) – Yes · seat 12Patrick Reslow (SD) – Yes · seat 13Rasmus Ling (MP) – Yes · seat 14Hans Wallmark (M) – Absent · seat 15Björn Söder (SD) – Absent · seat 16Gunilla Carlsson (S) – No · seat 17Mattias Jonsson (S) – Absent · seat 18Johan Hultberg (M) – Yes · seat 19Ida Ekeroth Clausson (S) – No · seat 20Patrik Björck (S) – No · seat 21Peter Hultqvist (S) – No · seat 22Anders W Jonsson (C) – Absent · seat 23Mats Berglund (MP) – Yes · seat 24Carl Nordblom (M) – Yes · seat 25Jessica Rosencrantz (M) – Yes · seat 26Fredrik Malm (L) – Yes · seat 27Ingela Nylund Watz (S) – No · seat 28Yusuf Aydin (KD) – Yes · seat 29Anna af Sillén (M) – Absent · seat 30Caroline Helmersson Olsson (S) – No · seat 31Hans Ekström (S) – No · seat 32Anders Karlsson (C) – Yes · seat 33Jimmie Åkesson (SD) – Absent · seat 34Jamal El-Haj (–) – No · seat 35Malcolm Momodou Jallow (V) – Abstained · seat 36Joakim Sandell (S) – Absent · seat 37Per-Arne Håkansson (S) – No · seat 38Magnus Persson (SD) – Yes · seat 39Rickard Nordin (C) – Absent · seat 40Jimmy Ståhl (SD) – Yes · seat 41Maj Karlsson (V) – Abstained · seat 42Markus Wiechel (SD) – Yes · seat 43Ulrika Heie (C) – Yes · seat 44Sten Bergheden (M) – Yes · seat 45Crister Carlsson (M) – Yes · seat 46Rasmus Giertz (SD) – Yes · seat 47Lars Beckman (M) – Yes · seat 48Roger Hedlund (SD) – Yes · seat 49Andreas Lennkvist Manriquez (V) – Abstained · seat 50Karin Rågsjö (V) – Abstained · seat 51Maria Stockhaus (M) – Yes · seat 52Magdalena Andersson (S) – Absent · seat 53Leif Nysmed (S) – No · seat 54Åsa Westlund (S) – No · seat 55Adam Marttinen (SD) – Yes · seat 56Lotta Johnsson Fornarve (V) – Absent · seat 57Martina Johansson (C) – Yes · seat 58Ann-Sofie Lifvenhage (M) – Absent · seat 59Mats Green (M) – Yes · seat 60Johanna Haraldsson (S) – No · seat 61Emelie Nyman (C) – Yes · seat 62Noria Manouchi (M) – Yes · seat 63Mikael Eskilandersson (SD) – Yes · seat 64Lars Johnsson (M) – Yes · seat 65Anna Wallentheim (S) – No · seat 66Thomas Morell (SD) – Yes · seat 67Johan Büser (S) – No · seat 68Robert Hannah (L) – Absent · seat 69Jonathan Svensson (S) – No · seat 70Magnus Jacobsson (KD) – Yes · seat 71Erik Ezelius (S) – No · seat 72Jörgen Grubb (SD) – Yes · seat 73Sara Gille (SD) – Yes · seat 74Sofie Eriksson (S) – No · seat 75Patrik Lundqvist (S) – No · seat 76Viktor Wärnick (M) – Yes · seat 77Fredrik Lundh Sammeli (S) – No · seat 78Birger Lahti (V) – Absent · seat 79Unni Björnerfors (SD) – Yes · seat 80Lawen Redar (S) – No · seat 81Adam Reuterskiöld (M) – Yes · seat 82Martin Kinnunen (SD) – Yes · seat 83Nooshi Dadgostar (V) – Abstained · seat 84Alexandra Völker (S) – No · seat 85Sofia Amloh (S) – No · seat 86Linus Lakso (MP) – Absent · seat 87Johan Löfstrand (S) – No · seat 88Susanne Nordström (M) – Yes · seat 89Carina Ödebrink (S) – No · seat 90Camilla Rinaldo Miller (KD) – Yes · seat 91Rose-Marie Carlsson (S) – Absent · seat 92Peter Ollén (M) – Yes · seat 93Ewa Pihl Krabbe (S) – No · seat 94Torsten Elofsson (KD) – Yes · seat 95Jennie Nilsson (S) – No · seat 96Adnan Dibrani (S) – No · seat 97Dennis Dioukarev (SD) – Yes · seat 98Marie-Louise Hänel Sandström (M) – Yes · seat 99Mats Wiking (S) – No · seat 100Ann-Sofie Alm (M) – Yes · seat 101Dan Hovskär (KD) – Absent · seat 102Tobias Andersson (SD) – Yes · seat 103Malin Höglund (M) – Yes · seat 104Kajsa Fredholm (V) – Abstained · seat 105Kristoffer Lindberg (S) – No · seat 106Lili André (KD) – Absent · seat 107Ida Karkiainen (S) – No · seat 108Linus Sköld (S) – No · seat 109Mattias Vepsä (S) – No · seat 110Kristina Axén Olin (M) – Yes · seat 111Ida Drougge (M) – Yes · seat 112Daniel Riazat (V) – Abstained · seat 113Robert Stenkvist (SD) – Yes · seat 114Azadeh Rojhan (S) – No · seat 115Mikael Oscarsson (KD) – Yes · seat 116Mattias Eriksson Falk (SD) – Yes · seat 117Johan Andersson (S) – No · seat 118Göran Hargestam (SD) – Yes · seat 119Staffan Eklöf (SD) – Yes · seat 120Eric Westroth (SD) – Yes · seat 121Louise Eklund (L) – Yes · seat 122Nima Gholam Ali Pour (SD) – Yes · seat 123Morgan Johansson (S) – No · seat 124Boriana Åberg (M) – Yes · seat 125Larry Söder (KD) – Yes · seat 126Lars Püss (M) – Yes · seat 127David Josefsson (M) – Yes · seat 128Leila Ali Elmi (MP) – Absent · seat 129Matheus Enholm (SD) – Absent · seat 130Louise Thunström (S) – No · seat 131Charlotte Nordström (M) – Yes · seat 132Lars Mejern Larsson (S) – No · seat 133Ulrika Liljeberg (C) – Yes · seat 134Lars Isacsson (S) – No · seat 135Daniel Persson (SD) – Yes · seat 136Samuel Gonzalez Westling (V) – Abstained · seat 137Eric Palmqvist (SD) – Yes · seat 138Mattias Karlsson (M) – Yes · seat 139Martin Ådahl (C) – Yes · seat 140Lorena Delgado Varas (V) – Absent · seat 141Annika Strandhäll (S) – No · seat 142Serkan Köse (S) – Absent · seat 143Mathias Tegnér (S) – No · seat 144Annika Hirvonen (MP) – Yes · seat 145Fredrik Ahlstedt (M) – Yes · seat 146Ardalan Shekarabi (S) – No · seat 147Magnus Oscarsson (KD) – Yes · seat 148Mattias Ottosson (S) – No · seat 149Ciczie Weidby (V) – Abstained · seat 150Jakob Olofsgård (L) – Yes · seat 151Richard Jomshof (SD) – Yes · seat 152Magnus Manhammar (S) – No · seat 153Camilla Mårtensen (L) – Yes · seat 154Marianne Fundahn (S) – No · seat 155Sara-Lena Bjälkö (SD) – Yes · seat 156Helena Storckenfeldt (M) – Absent · seat 157Tony Haddou (V) – Abstained · seat 158Emma Nohrén (MP) – Absent · seat 159Jan Ericson (M) – Yes · seat 160Petter Löberg (S) – No · seat 161Gunilla Svantorp (S) – No · seat 162Daniel Bäckström (C) – Yes · seat 163Anna-Lena Hedberg (SD) – Absent · seat 164Mathias Bengtsson (KD) – Absent · seat 165Sanna Backeskog (S) – No · seat 166Linnéa Wickman (S) – Absent · seat 167Johnny Svedin (SD) – Yes · seat 168Zara Leghissa (S) – No · seat 169Camilla Brodin (KD) – Absent · seat 170Ida Gabrielsson (V) – Abstained · seat 171Arin Karapet (M) – Yes · seat 172Henrik Vinge (SD) – Yes · seat 173Erik Ottoson (M) – Yes · seat 174Gulan Avci (L) – Yes · seat 175Anna Vikström (S) – No · seat 176Alexandra Anstrell (M) – Yes · seat 177Sanne Lennström (S) – No · seat 178Gustaf Lantz (S) – No · seat 179Linda W Snecker (V) – Absent · seat 180Teresa Carvalho (S) – No · seat 181Azra Muranovic (S) – Absent · seat 182Niklas Sigvardsson (S) – No · seat 183Heléne Björklund (S) – No · seat 184Ann-Christine Frohm (SD) – Yes · seat 185Ann-Charlotte Hammar Johnsson (M) – Yes · seat 186Carina Ståhl Herrstedt (SD) – Yes · seat 187Lars Andersson (SD) – Yes · seat 188Hanna Gunnarsson (V) – Abstained · seat 189Jan Riise (MP) – Yes · seat 190Carita Boulwén (SD) – Absent · seat 191Björn Tidland (SD) – Yes · seat 192Magnus Berntsson (KD) – Yes · seat 193Patrik Jönsson (SD) – Yes · seat 194Ingemar Kihlström (KD) – Absent · seat 195Runar Filper (SD) – Yes · seat 196Mikael Dahlkvist (S) – No · seat 197Elin Nilsson (L) – Yes · seat 198Matilda Ernkrans (S) – No · seat 199Olle Thorell (S) – No · seat 200Oscar Sjöstedt (SD) – Yes · seat 201Saila Quicklund (M) – Yes · seat 202Anette Rangdag (SD) – Yes · seat 203Helén Pettersson (S) – No · seat 204Isak From (S) – No · seat 205Joar Forssell (L) – Yes · seat 206Malin Danielsson (L) – Yes · seat 207Kadir Kasirga (S) – No · seat 208Malin Björk (C) – Yes · seat 209Markus Selin (S) – No · seat 210Kjell Jansson (M) – Yes · seat 211Alireza Akhondi (C) – Yes · seat 212Ludvig Aspling (SD) – Yes · seat 213Ilona Szatmári Waldau (V) – Abstained · seat 214Lina Nordquist (L) – Yes · seat 215Aron Emilsson (SD) – Yes · seat 216Eva Lindh (S) – No · seat 217Tomas Eneroth (S) – No · seat 218Mattias Karlsson Bergman (SD) – Yes · seat 219Lena Hallengren (S) – No · seat 220Camilla Brunsberg (M) – Absent · seat 221Niklas Karlsson (S) – No · seat 222Yasmine Bladelius (S) – No · seat 223Emma Berginger (MP) – Yes · seat 224Louise Meijer (M) – Absent · seat 225Christofer Bergenblock (C) – Yes · seat 226Cecilia Rönn (L) – Absent · seat 227Dzenan Cisija (S) – No · seat 228Amalia Rud Stenlöf (S) – Absent · seat 229Mikael Larsson (C) – Yes · seat 230Ulrik Nilsson (M) – Yes · seat 231Håkan Svenneling (V) – Abstained · seat 232Magnus Resare (M) – Absent · seat 233Katarina Tolgfors (M) – Yes · seat 234Helena Vilhelmsson (C) – Absent · seat 235Åsa Eriksson (S) – No · seat 236Vasiliki Tsouplaki (V) – Abstained · seat 237Anna-Caren Sätherberg (S) – No · seat 238Kalle Olsson (S) – No · seat 239Helena Lindahl (C) – Yes · seat 240Edward Riedl (M) – Yes · seat 241Katarina Luhr (MP) – Yes · seat 242Mirja Räihä (S) – No · seat 243Daniel Helldén (MP) – Absent · seat 244Elsa Widding (–) – Absent · seat 245Josefin Malmqvist (M) – Yes · seat 246Fredrik Lindahl (SD) – Yes · seat 247Joanna Lewerentz (M) – Yes · seat 248Liza-Maria Norlin (KD) – Yes · seat 249Kent Kumpula (SD) – Yes · seat 250Catarina Deremar (C) – Yes · seat 251John Widegren (M) – Yes · seat 252Patrik Karlson (L) – Yes · seat 253Monica Haider (S) – No · seat 254Katja Nyberg (SD) – Yes · seat 255Mattias Bäckström Johansson (SD) – Yes · seat 256Laila Naraghi (S) – No · seat 257Mauricio Rojas (L) – Yes · seat 258Ulrika Heindorff (M) – Yes · seat 259Stina Larsson (C) – Yes · seat 260Cecilia Engström (KD) – Yes · seat 261Erik Hellsborn (SD) – Yes · seat 262Aida Birinxhiku (S) – No · seat 263Roland Utbult (KD) – Yes · seat 264Gustaf Göthberg (M) – Yes · seat 265Anders Alftberg (SD) – Yes · seat 266Jessica Rodén (S) – Absent · seat 267Charlotte Quensel (SD) – Absent · seat 268Marléne Lund Kopparklint (M) – Yes · seat 269Hans Eklind (KD) – Yes · seat 270Denis Begic (S) – Absent · seat 271Angelica Lundberg (SD) – Yes · seat 272Mikael Damsgaard (M) – Yes · seat 273David Lång (SD) – Absent · seat 274Jörgen Berglund (M) – Absent · seat 275Björn Wiechel (S) – No · seat 276Åsa Karlsson (S) – No · seat 277Elisabeth Thand Ringqvist (C) – Yes · seat 278Markus Kallifatides (S) – No · seat 279Ulrika Westerlund (MP) – Yes · seat 280Jytte Guteland (S) – No · seat 281Mats Arkhem (SD) – Absent · seat 282Anna Starbrink (L) – Absent · seat 283Märta Stenevi (MP) – Yes · seat 284Anna Lasses (C) – Yes · seat 285Inga-Lill Sjöblom (S) – Absent · seat 286Lars Wistedt (SD) – Yes · seat 287Clara Aranda (SD) – Yes · seat 288Jonas Andersson (SD) – Yes · seat 289Thomas Ragnarsson (M) – Absent · seat 290Oliver Rosengren (M) – Yes · seat 291Tomas Kronståhl (S) – No · seat 292Gudrun Brunegård (KD) – Yes · seat 293Bo Broman (SD) – Yes · seat 294Linda Lindberg (SD) – Yes · seat 295Victoria Tiblom (SD) – Yes · seat 296Jessica Stegrud (SD) – Yes · seat 297Ellen Juntti (M) – Yes · seat 298Jennie Wernäng (M) – Yes · seat 299Janine Alm Ericson (MP) – Absent · seat 300Helena Gellerman (L) – Absent · seat 301Joakim Järrebring (S) – No · seat 302Alexander Christiansson (SD) – Yes · seat 303Kjell-Arne Ottosson (KD) – Absent · seat 304Sofia Skönnbrink (S) – No · seat 305Michael Rubbestad (SD) – Yes · seat 306Per Söderlund (SD) – Yes · seat 307Lena Johansson (S) – No · seat 308Eleonore Lundkvist (M) – Yes · seat 309Malin Larsson (S) – Absent · seat 310Anne-Li Sjölund (C) – Yes · seat 311Gudrun Nordborg (V) – Abstained · seat 312Pontus Andersson Garpvall (SD) – Yes · seat 313Fredrik Kärrholm (M) – Yes · seat 314Daniel Vencu Öhrlund Castro (S) – Absent · seat 315Martin Melin (L) – Yes · seat 316Martin Westmont (SD) – Yes · seat 317Amanda Lind (MP) – Absent · seat 318Andrea Andersson Tay (V) – Abstained · seat 319Beatrice Timgren (SD) – Absent · seat 320Leonid Yurkovskiy (SD) – Yes · seat 321Stefan Olsson (M) – Yes · seat 322Jacob Risberg (MP) – Yes · seat 323Rebecka Le Moine (MP) – Yes · seat 324John E. Weinerhall (M) – Yes · seat 325Muharrem Demirok (C) – Yes · seat 326Mona Olin (SD) – Yes · seat 327Lars Engsund (M) – Yes · seat 328Marie Nicholson (M) – Yes · seat 329Ola Möller (S) – Absent · seat 330Jonny Cato (C) – Yes · seat 331Emma Ahlström Köster (M) – Yes · seat 332Adrian Magnusson (S) – No · seat 333Jessica Wetterling (V) – Abstained · seat 334Yasmine Eriksson (SD) – Yes · seat 335Paula Örn (S) – No · seat 336Johanna Rantsi (M) – Yes · seat 337Anders Ådahl (C) – Yes · seat 338Rashid Farivar (SD) – Yes · seat 339Camilla Hansén (MP) – Yes · seat 340Karin Sundin (S) – No · seat 341Nadja Awad (V) – Abstained · seat 342Oskar Svärd (M) – Yes · seat 343Anna-Belle Strömberg (S) – No · seat 344Ulf Lindholm (SD) – Yes · seat 345Peder Björk (S) – No · seat 346Isabell Mixter (V) – Absent · seat 347Peter Hedberg (S) – No · seat 348Elin Söderberg (MP) – Yes · seat 349
  • 180 yes
  • 93 no
  • 19 abstained
  • 57 absent

Decision items

  1. 1

    Riksrevisionens rapport Svart på vitt - rotavdragets kostnader och effekter

    Riksdagen lägger skrivelse 2023/24:125 till handlingarna.

    acklamation

    utskottet

The debate in the chamber

29 speeches

Speeches are shown in the original Swedish.

Loading speeches…